Contact Us

Please contact us for further information:

[email protected]

1300 720 004

Testimonials

Finally - an HR service which we can depend on and refer clients to with confidence!  We are continually asked for advice concerning employment related matters which in the past we have inefficiently sourced. Hence we have searched and found a company that can satisfy the needs of our growing client base – HR Advice Online.  We have had much positive feedback from clients in relation to HR Advice Online’s service offering. One particular restaurant business had issues with employment contracts which continued to exist after seeking guidance from several perceived experts. Their issues were promptly rectified after subscription with HR Advice Online. They were extremely happy and thanked us for referring them to HR Advice Online.... HR Advice Online has not only assisted our clients but us too as a firm.

- David Cassarino, Partner, Andresen McCarthy Partners, Accountants and Business Advisors

Alleged Bullies - Duty of Care Owed

Alleged bullies – Do “duty of care” obligations still apply?

A court ruling has highlighted the requirement for employers to maintain their duty of care to those employees who have had allegations of bullying made against them before, during and after a bullying investigation has taken place.
 
The case involved four employees from an office of Disability Services Queensland who had allegations of bullying and harassment made against them in 2008 and again in 2009. The claims were supported by the Union, however a subsequent investigation conducted by the employer could not substantiate the allegations made against the four employees.
 
The four employees each subsequently brought claims against the employer alleging they were owed a duty of care by the employer both when the initial complaints were made and during the investigation. It was alleged that the lack of support provided and the subsequent breach of this duty led to psychiatric problems.
 
While the District Court initially dismissed the claims, the Queensland Court of Appeal found that a duty of care did exist for three out of four of these cases. In the final judgement made in the case, Justice Dalton found that “There is no doubt that in appropriate circumstances an employer will owe a duty of care to take reasonable steps to prevent psychiatric injury to an employee”. It was held that the duty will occur if a psychiatric injury is reasonably foreseeable in each employee’s case.
 
As complaints were made in 2008 and then again in 2009, it was held that the employer should have been aware there would be a substantial investigation conducted. The employer was found to have breached their duty of care by failing to provide any support except for offering a free departmental counselling service and removing certain employees from their roles. It was held that the employer should have recognised that each employee may suffer harm due to support not having been offered to the four employees.
 
During the investigation process, there were some instances in which the four employees were required to work alongside the complainants, and were subject to picketing by the union. Some of the four employees were found to have been segregated and isolated from their colleagues in the workplace.
 
In all cases however, there was insufficient evidence to support that any of the employer’s breaches of duty led to psychiatric injury being suffered.
 
For the employee for whom no duty was owed, the court found that they did not lose their “substantiative position” during the investigation. Rather they were moved to a new role which they had requested and was somewhat insulated from the workplace conflict.
 
This set the one employee apart from the remaining three employees who had to spend considerable time working in stressful conditions with those who had lodged serious claims against them.

Information in HR Advice Online guides and blog posts is meant purely for educational discussion of human resources issues. It contains only general information about human resources matters and due to factors such as government legislation changes, may not be up-to-date at the time of reading. It is not legal advice and should not be treated as such.
  

Welcome to HR Advice Online

To subscribe to our content and download our resource tools, you first need to be a registered user on our site. Please register first and you will be redirected to our Membership Page.

Member Login

Username:
Password:
Forgot Password ?  

Not a member yet? Sign Up!

Australia's Leading Online HR & Safety Advisory Service. 1300 720 004
Privacy Statement     Terms Of Use     Website Powered by SBM     © HR Advice OnLine Pty Ltd